Skip to content

EU Auditors Say Weak Data Sharing Between Member States Is Leaving Europe’s Cyber Defenses Exposed

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

EU Auditors Say Weak Data Sharing Between Member States Is Leaving Europe’s Cyber Defenses Exposed

Europe has spent years building an elaborate web of institutions meant to detect and respond to major cyberattacks, but a new assessment from the bloc’s independent spending watchdog says that architecture is only doing part of its job, largely because member states still won’t reliably tell each other what’s actually happening when something goes wrong.

The European Court of Auditors laid out its findings in a special report published Monday, covering the period from 2022 through 2025. Its overall verdict was blunt: the EU’s cooperation framework for detecting and responding to serious cyber incidents is making progress, but it’s only partially delivering on what it was designed to do. The auditors pinned most of the blame on three overlapping problems, limited information exchange between countries, gaps in how incidents actually get reported, and repeated delays in getting agreed measures up and running in practice.

The scale of the investment involved makes the shortfall harder to shrug off. The EU is currently funneling €1.4 billion, roughly $1.61 billion, into cybersecurity efforts as part of its current budget cycle, alongside a genuinely dense set of institutions built specifically for this purpose: a network of national computer emergency response teams, a dedicated crisis management structure, a cybersecurity reserve, and a bloc-wide alert system. On paper, that’s a serious, well-resourced attempt to give Europe a coordinated defense against attacks that routinely ignore national borders. In practice, the auditors found the system’s weakest link sits exactly where coordination matters most, describing poor information sharing as effectively the fatal flaw undermining everything built around it.

Real More:  Cybercrime Feud Erupts on Dark Web as ShinyHunters Claims It Hijacked Rival Gang cl0p's Site

Part of the problem traces back to national law rather than any shortfall in EU-level planning. According to the report, individual countries can classify information about attacks on critical infrastructure as restricted under their own domestic security legislation, and once that classification is applied, they face no obligation to pass that information along to other member states, even when an attack has clearly crossed borders. The auditors noted that nobody has actually mapped out, EU-wide, just how much these national restrictions are choking off cross-border cooperation, and they’ve now recommended that exactly this kind of analysis get carried out.

The consequences of that gap aren’t hypothetical. The report pointed specifically to a ransomware attack in September 2025 targeting a technology provider used across the aviation sector, an incident that ended up disrupting check-in and boarding systems at major airports including London, Brussels, Berlin and Dublin. That single attack rippling across several countries’ aviation infrastructure at once is precisely the kind of scenario the EU’s cross-border alert mechanisms were supposed to handle smoothly, and the auditors used it as a clear illustration of how badly the current system can stumble when speed and shared visibility actually matter.

Perhaps the most telling data point in the entire report has nothing to do with any single incident. Despite the EU having a formal category for “large-scale” cybersecurity incidents, defined as any attack affecting at least two member states, not a single country has actually reported an incident under that label since 2016. That’s not because cross-border attacks stopped happening; the EU’s own cybersecurity agency, ENISA, tallied 322 separate incidents in 2024 alone that specifically hit two or more member states at once. The near decade-long gap between zero formal large-scale reports and hundreds of qualifying incidents each year says less about the frequency of cross-border attacks and more about how reluctant, or how legally constrained, countries remain when it comes to formally flagging them.

Real More:  CrowdStrike Says South Korean Bank Cyberattacks Likely Came From China-Based Actor Using AI Agent ARTEX and Claude Code

Enforcement pressure has already started building on a related front. In July, the European Commission referred France, Ireland, the Netherlands and Spain to the EU’s Court of Justice, accusing all four of failing to update their national laws to reflect the bloc’s own rules on sharing cybersecurity information, a legal action that underscores just how uneven implementation has been even among some of the EU’s largest and most digitally developed member states.

The newer infrastructure meant to fix this coordination gap hasn’t fared much better so far. Under the EU’s Cyber Solidarity Act, smaller clusters of member states have been organized into regional cross-border cyber hubs designed to detect threats faster by working in tighter coordination than the full 27-country bloc can manage on its own. Two such hubs currently exist, one grouping Bulgaria, Greece, Cyprus and Malta, and another covering Spain, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Austria, Portugal and Romania, with a third hub receiving funding this year that would bring the total network to 20 participating countries. At the time the auditors conducted their review, though, neither of the two existing hubs was actually operational yet, meaning the mechanism specifically built to solve this exact coordination problem was still sitting on the sidelines rather than doing any real work.

Real More:  OpenAI, Anthropic CEOs Summoned to Australian Senate AI Inquiry

The timing of the audit’s release lands during a genuinely busy stretch for EU tech and data policy more broadly. The same week, Ireland’s Data Protection Commission fined Google €403 million, about $463 million, over how the company handled location data collected through its Web & App Activity setting, a separate but parallel reminder that Europe’s regulatory machinery around data, whether it’s protecting citizens’ personal information or defending critical infrastructure from attack, remains a work in progress across multiple fronts at once.

For now, the Court of Auditors‘ message is fairly direct: Europe has built an impressive amount of cybersecurity architecture, but architecture alone doesn’t stop an attack. Without member states actually willing to share what they know, when they know it, the systems built to catch the next cross-border cyberattack risk finding out about it the same way the public usually does, after the damage is already done.

Leave a Comment