|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
The African Democratic Congress (ADC) has approached the Court of Appeal to overturn a Federal High Court judgment that nullified its David Mark-led leadership structure and invalidated decisions taken under the party’s caretaker administration, including the process that produced Atiku Abubakar as its presidential candidate for the 2027 election.
The opposition party is also seeking an order restraining the Independent National Electoral Commission from changing its leadership records or tampering with the nomination details of its presidential and governorship candidates until the appellate court determines the case.
ADC announced the appeal through a statement issued on Tuesday, November 17, by Phrank Shaibu, Director of Strategic Communication of the party’s Presidential Campaign Council. The appeal raises 17 grounds against the judgment delivered by Justice Peter Lifu of the Federal High Court in Abuja on November 5, 2026.
ADC Challenges Federal High Court’s Jurisdiction
A major issue in the appeal concerns whether the Federal High Court had the jurisdiction to determine the dispute over the ADC’s internal leadership arrangements.
The party argues that the case involved an internal party matter that the trial court lacked the authority to decide in the manner presented. It is asking the Court of Appeal to examine the legal foundation of the judgment and determine whether the trial court properly exercised its jurisdiction.
The ADC is also questioning the legal standing of the claimant, Nafiu Bala Gombe, to institute the action. Gombe, a former ADC Deputy National Chairman for the North-East, challenged the process through which the David Mark-led leadership emerged.
According to the party, the 17 grounds of appeal also address the trial court’s assessment of disputed evidence and the scope of the orders it issued against the ADC.
The party’s position is that the judgment should not stand because of what it considers fundamental errors in the proceedings and the court’s findings.
Party Disputes Judgment Over Earlier July 2026 Ruling
The ADC has raised questions about an earlier Federal High Court judgment delivered on July 2, 2026, concerning the party’s leadership transition.
It maintains that the earlier decision remained valid and had not been set aside when Justice Lifu delivered the November 5 judgment. The party is therefore asking the appellate court to examine how the trial court handled the earlier ruling and whether it properly considered its legal implications.
The dispute also involves a separate ruling delivered on July 24, 2026, which allowed Gombe to amend his originating summons.
The ADC is challenging that decision because the trial court deferred its ruling on the party’s preliminary objection to jurisdiction while granting permission for the amendment.
The party argues that the amendment changed the description of the parties and the capacity in which a defendant was sued without obtaining the required prior leave of court.
Its legal team wants the Court of Appeal to set aside the amendment order and determine the outstanding jurisdictional objection.
Chief J.S. Okutepa, a Senior Advocate of Nigeria, settled the appellant’s brief challenging the July 24 ruling.
ADC Asks Court of Appeal to Stop INEC From Altering Candidate Records
Beyond seeking to overturn the judgment, the ADC wants the appellate court to protect its existing leadership and candidate records while the legal challenge continues.
The party is asking the court to restrain INEC from altering its leadership records or interfering with the names and nomination particulars of its presidential and governorship candidates.
The application is intended to prevent the electoral commission from taking administrative steps that could affect the party’s candidates before the Court of Appeal reaches a decision.
The ADC argues that implementing the November 5 judgment before the appeal is determined could create complications that may be difficult to reverse, even if the appellate court eventually rules in its favour.
Phrank Shaibu said the party wants the court to preserve the subject of the appeal so that its eventual decision can have practical effect.
However, filing an appeal or requesting an injunction does not automatically suspend the Federal High Court judgment. The Court of Appeal must consider the party’s application before any requested protective order can take effect.
Why the Court Nullified Atiku’s ADC Presidential Nomination
Justice Peter Lifu delivered the judgment on November 5 in a case brought by Gombe over the emergence of the David Mark-led ADC leadership.
The court declared the Mark-led caretaker committee’s emergence unlawful and nullified actions taken under its authority. These included the processes through which the party conducted its presidential primary and produced Atiku as its flag bearer for the 2027 election.
The judgment also affected the emergence of former Interior Minister Rauf Aregbesola as National Secretary and the nominations of other candidates presented by the party for the 2027 elections.
The court directed INEC not to recognise or act on decisions taken at the ADC’s 99th National Executive Committee meeting held on July 27, 2025.
Gombe had challenged the leadership transition that followed the departure of former National Chairman Ralph Nwosu and the emergence of the caretaker leadership headed by former Senate President David Mark in July 2025.
The ruling created uncertainty around the party’s leadership structure and its preparations for the 2027 general elections.
Atiku’s 2027 Presidential Bid Faces Continuing Legal Uncertainty
The appeal adds another stage to the legal dispute surrounding Atiku’s candidacy and the ADC’s participation in the 2027 presidential election.
The former Vice-President emerged as the party’s presidential candidate after its primary in May 2026. The November 5 judgment subsequently invalidated the process that produced his nomination.
ADC leaders have maintained that the party will continue to pursue the legal challenge and defend the decisions taken under the Mark-led leadership.
The latest appeal does not, by itself, reverse the Federal High Court judgment or confirm that INEC must retain the disputed candidate records. Those questions depend on the decisions of the appellate court and any interim orders it may issue.
For now, the central issue is whether the Court of Appeal will uphold the ADC’s arguments, set aside the November 5 judgment and grant the requested protection against changes to the party’s records.
The outcome will have implications for Atiku’s presidential nomination, the party’s other candidates and the ADC’s preparations for the 2027 elections.