Skip to content

Jimmy Odukoya Takes Sister Tolu and Seven Church Trustees to Court Over Removal as Senior Pastor

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Pastor Jimmy Odukoya has filed a lawsuit against his sister, Pastor Tolu Odukoya, and seven other members of The Fountain of Life Church’s Board of Trustees, challenging the decision to remove him as the church’s senior pastor.

The case, filed at the Federal High Court in Lagos on November 20, 2026, is the latest development in the leadership crisis that has divided the Lagos-based church following disagreements over its succession arrangements and governing constitution.

Odukoya filed the suit alongside the Incorporated Trustees of The Fountain of Life Church. The eight defendants are Tolu Odukoya, Biodun Balogun, Biodun Awosika, Pastor Rotimi Okpaise, Pastor Tobi Enuha, Pastor Gbenga Onabanjo, Pastor Fred Ohiani and Pastor Akin Osinbajo.

The case, marked FHC/LAG/CS/1568/2026, seeks to establish whether the meetings and resolutions used to justify Odukoya’s removal complied with the church’s constitution. The court documents include an originating summons, a motion on notice and affidavits sworn to by the pastor in support of his application. Punch Newspapers+2

In the originating summons, Odukoya is asking the court to determine the validity of meetings held by some members of the church’s Board of Trustees on January 22, February 28 and November 16, 2026.

He argues that the meetings were not properly convened and that the decisions reached during those gatherings violated the church’s constitution. He is also asking the court to determine whether the trustees could separate the offices of senior pastor and chairman of the Board of Trustees, amend the church’s constitution or remove a senior pastor without following the procedures prescribed by the governing document.

Odukoya maintains that he was appointed senior pastor and chairman of the Board of Trustees at an emergency meeting on September 14, 2023, before being formally installed later that month. According to his affidavit, the appointment followed the death of the church’s founder, Pastor Taiwo Odukoya, in August 2023.

He contends that the appointment was valid and that the trustees cannot overturn it through meetings or resolutions that do not comply with the church’s constitutional provisions. Punch Newspapers+2

The pastor’s account traces the disagreement to a Board of Trustees meeting held on December 19, 2025, which was attended by Bishop Mike Okonkwo. During the meeting, the possibility of transferring the church’s administrative responsibilities to the associate senior pastor was reportedly discussed.

Real More:  Malawi Moves to Cut Smartphone Taxes

Odukoya said no final resolution was reached at that meeting. He subsequently convened another board meeting for January 5, 2026, but it could not hold because there was no quorum.

He alleged that some trustees later presented proposals to him, several of which he rejected because he considered them inconsistent with the church’s constitution. He also said the trustees sent him a letter dated January 7 requesting a response within three days, but he did not see the letter until after the deadline had passed.

The disagreement intensified over a proposed board meeting scheduled for January 22. Odukoya alleged that the notice was circulated by one of the defendants rather than through the church’s board secretariat. He said he received it late on January 20, leaving him with approximately one day’s notice, and therefore declined to attend.

According to his court affidavit, the trustees proceeded with the gathering under the description of concerned members of the Board. He alleged that they adopted resolutions separating the offices of senior pastor and board chairman, suspending the board secretary and another pastor, dissolving the church’s Executive Council and amending its constitution.

Odukoya disputed the authority of those involved to take such decisions outside the procedures established by the church’s governing document. Punch Newspapers+1

The pastor further alleged that another disputed meeting took place on February 28, 2026, where a vote was conducted and he was purportedly removed as chairman of the Board of Trustees.

He said he challenged the decision in a letter dated March 2, maintaining that the gathering was neither a properly constituted board meeting nor a valid meeting of the church council.

Attempts to resolve the disagreement through meetings and correspondence reportedly continued over the following months. However, the conflict resurfaced in November when notices were circulated for another board meeting scheduled for November 16.

Odukoya said he objected to the process in a letter dated November 15, but the meeting went ahead. On November 17, the trustees communicated a decision removing him as senior pastor and chairman of the Board of Trustees.

Real More:  Russia has unveiled a new anti-drone "Web" protective structure for its oil refineries

He has now asked the Federal High Court to declare the disputed meetings and the resolutions arising from them invalid. He is also seeking an injunction restraining the defendants from implementing the decisions or interfering with his functions and the management of the church pending the determination of the case. Punch Newspapers+2

The lawsuit comes after a separate legal action by the church’s trustees resulted in an interim order against Odukoya at the Lagos State High Court.

On November 18, Justice O. O. Adewunmi-Oshin restrained him from presenting himself as the senior pastor and spiritual head of The Fountain of Life Church. The order also prevented him from interfering with the church’s governance, administration and activities.

The order was granted ex parte, meaning it was issued at an initial stage without first hearing Odukoya’s response. However, the court’s directive expressly preserved his right to apply to have it set aside or to respond to the substantive claims.

The trustees had approached the Lagos State High Court arguing that Odukoya had ceased to hold the position following the appointment of a successor by the late founder in accordance with the church’s constitution. The matter was adjourned until December 1, 2026, for mention. Punch Newspapers+2

The leadership dispute became public on November 17, when a group identifying itself as the church’s Board of Trustees announced that Odukoya was no longer recognised as senior pastor.

In explaining the decision, the trustees referred to a video recording made by the late Taiwo Odukoya in December 2021. According to the group, the recording contained instructions about the church’s leadership succession that had not been presented to the trustees when Jimmy was appointed senior pastor in 2023.

The trustees said the late founder had designated Pastor Kunle Areogun as his preferred successor and assigned Jimmy an administrative support role and leadership of the youth ministry. They maintained that the recording and the relevant provisions of the church’s constitution required them to reconsider the leadership arrangement.

The board also raised concerns about Jimmy’s remarriage, arguing that the development conflicted with the church’s teachings and the standards expected of its spiritual leadership. These were among the reasons given in its public statement announcing his removal. Punch Newspapers+1

Real More:  UAE Pushes to Exit Foreign Travel Warning Lists as Dubai Hotel Occupancy Hits Highest Level Since Iran War Began

Odukoya and those supporting his leadership have rejected the trustees’ decision, insisting that his appointment in September 2023 was valid and had received the necessary approval. Their position is that the purported removal was not carried out in accordance with the church’s constitution.

The trustees subsequently named Pastor Rotimi Okpaise as the interim spiritual and administrative leader while consultations and arrangements for a substantive leadership structure continue.

The competing positions have placed the church’s constitution, the authority of its Board of Trustees and the interpretation of the late founder’s succession instructions at the centre of the dispute.

Odukoya’s latest application also raises concerns about the potential disruption of church activities. In his affidavit, he alleged that the defendants had plans to prevent him from performing his duties and could use law enforcement agents to enforce the disputed resolutions.

He warned that continued disagreement over the church’s leadership could lead to confrontation among members and a possible breach of peace. These claims are allegations contained in his court filings and have not been established by a final judicial decision.

The Federal High Court will now be asked to examine the validity of the disputed meetings and determine whether the decisions taken by the trustees complied with the church’s governing rules. The separate proceedings at the Lagos State High Court also remain relevant to the dispute.

For members of The Fountain of Life Church, the outcome could determine who has the authority to lead the institution and how its leadership succession should be handled. For now, neither side has secured a final judicial determination of the underlying constitutional disagreement.

The case therefore remains an ongoing legal dispute, with the Federal High Court proceedings adding another dimension to the leadership crisis following the late founder’s death in 2023.

Leave a Comment